For some owners, hotel revenue is moving in the right direction, but hoteliers know that doesn’t tell the whole story. Even when revenue holds steady, insurance has become one of the hardest costs to predict and control.
If you own a boutique property or small group of hotels, you likely don’t have a corporate risk team negotiating your renewal. We explain what you need to know about rising hotel insurance costs, what carriers now expect, and how to build insurance into your budget and year-end planning before your next renewal.
This article discusses human trafficking in the context of insurance coverage and staff training requirements. If you suspect trafficking at your property, contact local law enforcement or the National Human Trafficking Hotline, and find resources for owners and staff through AHLA’s No Room for Trafficking program or call (888) 373-7888 to reach the National Human Trafficking Hotline.
Why Insurance Is a Top Financial Pressure for Independent Hotels
In a March 2026 survey by the American Hotel & Lodging Association (AHLA), 43% of hotel owners named insurance premiums as one of their greatest financial pressures. Hotel owners aren’t just making assumptions; the rate data backs that up. IMA Financial Group’s Q1 2026 hospitality market report found that general liability rates rose 5% to 15% for operators with favorable loss histories and 15% to 30% for those without. Umbrella and excess liability rates rose 10% to 20%.
Owners are also getting less for their money. Hotel Dive reports that some carriers are removing coverages hotels depend on. This includes coverage for human trafficking, sexual abuse and molestation, and assault and battery. That leaves properties exposed to the same claims that are driving costs up.
For an independent hotel, these increases hit differently than for a large franchise. Some brands offer group insurance programs. An independent hotel usually buys coverage alone. A family-owned hotel usually buys coverage alone, so each increase comes directly out of margin.
So why are owners with clean loss histories still paying more?
Why Hotel Insurance Costs Keep Rising
Ten years ago, a claim for a guest who slipped and broke their wrist might have settled for a modest amount and been forgotten. Today, some hotels are seeing routine slip-and-fall claims become six-figure settlements, which may make their renewal significantly higher.
Two factors may be driving these changes: fewer carriers and bigger claims.
- Fewer carriers: The number of carriers writing hotel business has dropped from about 25 five years ago to about 10 today, according to a broker quoted by Hotel Dive. Less competition means less leverage for owners at renewal.
- Bigger claims: Large jury awards, often called nuclear verdicts, are still pushing claim costs higher across the industry. Since hotels are public-facing businesses, routine incidents carry more exposure than they used to.
Property coverage is the exception to the rising costs. Rates have eased in many areas this year for properties with favorable loss histories, so ask your broker whether your property terms have improved even if liability stays expensive.
Some states are acting against these rising costs. Florida and Georgia have tightened rules on attorney fees, damages, and bad-faith claims, and AHLA has said these changes are helping lower insurance costs, though Georgia’s 2025 reforms are still too new to measure. Most states have not taken similar action yet, so owners elsewhere should plan for continued pressure.
What Carriers Now Expect From Hotel Owners
Underwriters are looking beyond a property’s loss history and more closely at how it’s run.
- Documented annual staff training. Some carriers now require annual training on human trafficking awareness, sexual abuse prevention, and slip-and-fall prevention for all employees, not only managers. Remember, document everything: sign-in sheets, completion records, and dates all matter for the training to count.
- Attention to online reviews. Underwriters are reviewing public-facing information. One broker told Hotel Dive that certain carriers won’t consider properties rated below 3.5 on TripAdvisor. Your review score may now factor into your risk profile.
- A complete, organized submission. Brokers quoted by Hotel Dive recommend that owners prepare their own submission documents, provide complete loss information, and meet with underwriters directly when possible.
These steps take time and money, but they help staff better recognize and respond to the issues behind many liability claims. Treat them as risk management so they aren’t trimmed when margins get tight, as they are important to protect guests, workers, and your coverage.

What Is Total Cost of Risk?
When a renewal quote comes in high, it’s tempting to lower property values or reduce business interruption coverage to bring the premium down. This can backfire when a claim exceeds the policy limits.
A better way to evaluate your coverage is total cost of risk, which adds up everything risk costs your property including the premium:
- Premium across all policies
- Deductibles and self-insured retentions
- Uninsured losses, including anything excluded from coverage
- Risk management costs such as training, maintenance, and review response
- Premium financing costs, if you finance your policy
Saving a few thousand dollars on premium means little if a kitchen fire takes 30 rooms offline for two months and your business interruption limit covers only part of your lost income, payroll, and debt service.
Looking at total cost of risk turns insurance from a fixed bill into part of your hotel cost control strategy. A broker who specializes in hospitality can help you understand exclusions and coverage options.
Why Insurance Belongs in Hotel Year-End Tax Planning
Insurance is as much a financial decision as a risk decision. Here is how to bring it into your hotel accounting and planning.
Budget insurance as its own line item. Track total insurance cost per available room and as a percentage of total revenue, year over year. Under the Uniform System of Accounts for the Lodging Industry (USALI), insurance is reported below gross operating profit. That means a property can show healthy GOP while rising premiums quietly reduce EBITDA and the cash available for debt service. If you pay annually, record the premium as a prepaid expense and recognize it monthly so each month’s P&L reflects your actual cost.
Review the numbers before renewal, not after. Before your broker goes to market, look at:
- Loss runs covering the past several years
- Property values, and whether they reflect current replacement cost (underinsuring can trigger a coinsurance penalty on a partial loss)
- Business interruption limits compared with your current revenue, payroll, fixed costs, and debt service
- Deductible options compared with your cash reserves, since a higher deductible lowers premium but shifts more risk to you
Tie insurance into year-end tax planning. Business insurance premiums are generally deductible as ordinary and necessary expenses, but timing matters. Depending on your accounting method and policy term, paying a renewal before year-end may or may not create a deduction in the current year. Under the 12-month rule, a prepaid premium may be deductible in the year you pay it if the coverage doesn’t extend beyond the earlier of 12 months after it begins or the end of the tax year after the year you pay. Accrual-basis owners have additional rules to consider, so confirm the timing with your CPA.
Plan renovations with risk in mind. If a renovation is on your calendar, some upgrades that reduce risk, such as improved lighting, flooring, fire safety systems, or security cameras, may also qualify for accelerated depreciation. Under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, 100% bonus depreciation is permanent for qualifying property acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025, and a cost segregation study can help identify which components qualify.
Our article on bonus depreciation for hotel renovations covers this in detail.

Plan Your Renewal and Year-End Together
Rising hotel insurance costs are a reality for independent owners, but they don’t have to catch you off guard. When insurance is part of your budget, your renewal review, and your year-end plan, you can make coverage decisions based on the full financial picture instead of the premium alone.
Here are the steps you can take this month:
- Confirm your renewal date and plan to start the process at least 90 days before it.
- Request a loss run report from your current carrier.
- Gather staff training records and schedule annual training.
- Check your ratings and respond to recent reviews.
- Update property values, especially if you’ve renovated or plan to.
- Compare your business interruption limit to your current financials.
- Ask your broker for a written list of exclusions and anything removed since last year.
- Add insurance to your 2027 budget and year-end planning meeting with your CPA.
MBE CPAs works with independent and boutique hotel owners on budgeting, cost review, and year-end tax planning. If you have a renewal coming up or a renovation in the works, talk with our hospitality team about your hotel’s year-end plan.
This article is for general information only and is not insurance, legal, or tax advice. Consult your insurance broker and CPA about your specific situation.